POLITICAL ECONOMY OF THE MEDIA
Course Outline
________________________________
Lectures 1 & 2 - Introduction to political economy of the media
An examination of what political economy is and its relevance to the study of the media. An outline of the historical context in which political economy emerged as a "science" - especially the Enlightenment. Outline of the competing models of political economy as espoused byAdam Smith, Karl Marx, John Maynard Keynes and the monetarists.
Readings |
| Fred Inglis - "Institutions: the political economy of media." in Media Theory : An Introduction |
| R Barry Jones - The worlds of political economy. |
| Eric Roll - A History of Economic Thought: |
| Michael Barrett-Brown - Chapter 3 (on Adam Smith) and Chapter 6 (on Karl Marx) in - Models of Political Economy |
| Nicholas Garnham - "Contributions to a political economy of mass- communications" in Media Culture and Society edited by Richard Collins et al |
| Graham Murdoch and Peter Golding - The Political Economy of the Media (Anything in part one of book one). |
| Stuart Hall et al - Formations of Modernity |
Lecture 3 - Early history of the press and the Public sphere
Content An account of the development of the press in Ireland, Britain and the US, from its early beginnings in the 17th and 18th century as pamphlets to its mature form (circa 1950). This Lecture will focus in particular on the emergence of a free press during the 19th century, responding to the demand for a public forum in which "the public" could freely discuss the political issues of the day, in the wake of social changes engendered by the Enlightenment, Industrial Revolution etc. Examination of the growing political power of the press and its eventual achievement of the status of a "fourth estate of the body politic.", independent of political interference.
This is related to a discussion of the concept of the "Public Sphere" (Habermas), that space wherein the all citizens can freely discuss politics independent of the influence of the state or capital. The work of Jurgen Habermas, one of the primary theorists of the public sphere will be examined with a particular focus on his assertion that the openness of the public sphere has been undermined by the growth of the advertising and marketing industries.
Readings |
| Jurgen Habermas -The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere |
| James Curran - "The impact of advertising on the British mass media" in Media, Culture and Society edited by Richard Collins et al. |
| Sean Brierly - The Advertising Handbook: Chapter 1. |
| Peter Hamilton - "The Enlightenment and the Birth of Social Science" Chapter 1 in Formations of Modernity - Stuart Hall et al (Eds) |
| Philip Elliott - "Intellectuals, the 'information society' and the disappearance of the public sphere." in Media, Culture and Society edited by Richard Collins et al. |
| Nicholas Garnham - Capitalism and Communication : Chapter 7 "The Media and the Public Sphere" |
| Mark Poster "Cyberdemocracy: Internet and the Public Sphere" in David Porter (Ed.) Internet Culture. |
| Frank Webster - Theories of the Information Society - Chapter 6 "Information Management and Manipulation: Jurgen Habermas and the Decline of the Public Sphere." |
| Miriam Hansen "Early Cinema, Late Cinema: Transformations of the Public Sphere" inLinda Williams (ed.) Viewing Postions |
| David Held - Introduction to Critical Theory |
| Raymond Williams - Chapter on Press History in The Long Revolution |
| James Curran - Article on Press History in Mass Communications and Society |
| Brian Farrell. (ed.) - Chaps 1 -3 in Communications and Community in Ireland |
| Curran, J and Seaton, J - Part 1 of Power without Responsibility (5th Edition) |
| Hugh Oram - The Newspaper Book: A History of Newspapers in Ireland 1649 - 1983. |
| Thomas C. Leonard - The Power of the Press: The Birth of American Political Reporting |
| Also worth looking at from time to time is a library journal Javnost (The Public) which frequently addresses public sphere type issues. |
Lectures 4 & 5 - The Cultural Industry Concept and Technological Determinism
Theories of the Frankfurt School (focusing on Theodor Adorno & M. Horkheimer) regarding the implications of the "industrialisation" of art and culture in the age of mass production (Fordist mode of production) for the political influence of culture. Discussion of the political function of mass culture.
Technological determinism versus Cultural Determinism: what factors influence the "appearance" of new/innovative technologies. How might these competing theories explain technological developments in the field of the media (with a particular focus on the increasingly technology dependent film industry). Furthermore, what effects might the introduction of new technologies have on the content of the various of media industries?
Readings on Culture Industries (Theoretical approaches): |
| David Held - Introduction to Critical Theory |
| Adorno and Horkheimer - "The Culture Industry: Enlightenment as mass deception" in Mass Communications and Society edited by James Curran et al. |
| Walter Benjamin - "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction" in Mass Communications and Society edited by James Curran et al. |
| Adorno, Theodor - "On Popular Music" from Cultural Theory and Popular Culture edited by John Storey. |
| Theodor Adorno - The Culture Industry: Selected Essays on Mass Culture |
| William Van Reijen - Adorno: An Introduction. |
| Edward S. Herman & Noam Chomsky - Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media |
Readings on Culture Industries (or Theory applied): |
| Nicholas Garnham - "Public Policy and the Cultural Industries" in Capitalism and Communication |
| Culture Industries - published by UNESCO |
| Mattelart, Michele - "Women and the Cultural Industries" in Media, Culture and Society |
Readings on Technological Determinism, Cultural Determinism and Social Shaping: |
| Merritt Roe Smith & Leo Marx (Eds.) - Does Technology Drive History?: The Dilemma of Technological Determinism |
| Raymond Williams - Television: Technology and cultural form. |
| Wiebe E. Bijker - Of Bicycles, Bakelites and Bulbs: Towards a Theory of sociotechnical change |
| Brian Winston - Media Technology and Society, A History: From the Telegraph to the Internet |
| Brian Winston - "How Media are Born" in Questioning the Media edited by Downing et al. |
| Ed Buscombe - "Sound and Colour" in Movies and Methods Volume II edited by Bill Nichols. |
| Robert C Allen & Douglas Gomery - Film history: Theory and Practice: Chp 5: "Technological Film History", Chp 5. |
| Donald Cardwell - The Fontana History of Technology |
| Frank Webster - Theories of the Information Society - Chapter 4. |
| For more general background reading perhaps examine: |
| Marshall McLuhan - Understanding Media |
| Alvin Toffler - Third Wave or Future Shock |
| Daniel Bell - The Coming of the Post- Industrial Society |
| Bill Gates - The Road Ahead |
Lectures 6 - 8 - Hollywood History
Account of the development of the cinema industry in America and Europe from a small cottage industry to a mass industry to a fully integrated industrial set-up (An application of the Fordist mode of production to film-making.). Tracing the development of the major studios and examine the effect of and the decline of the studio system. (Up to US vs. Paramount et al 1948, the anti-trust suit dismantling the vertical integration of the film industry). Discussion of the political economy of stars.
Examination of the development of Hollywood from 1950 up to the 1990s. The decline in Hollywood output and the perceived threat from television. Examination of the changing relationship between television and film and the growing integration of the two industries. Emergence of new markets for film product: video, pay-per-view television, etc. The growing integration of Hollywood studios with multimedia conglomerates.
Readings on Hollywood 1890 - 1948 |
| Ed Buscombe - "Sound and Colour" in Movies and Methods Volume II edited by Bill Nichols. |
| Thomas Schatz - Old Hollywood/New Hollywood: Ritual, Art and Society, Chp 2: "The Hollywood Studio System" |
| Robert C. Allen and Douglas Gomery - Film History: Theory and Practice, Chp 6 ("Economic Film History") |
| Michael Chanan - "Economic Conditions of Early Cinema" in Early Cinema: Space, Frame and Narrative edited by Thomas Elsaesser. |
| Graeme Turner - Chapter 1 in Film as Social Practice (for a brief yet helpful introduction to the industrial structure of Hollywood) |
| Thomas Guback "Non-market factors in the distribution of American Films" in Bruce A. Austin (ed.) Current Reseach in Film, Volume 1. |
For a good comparative history of an early European film history see:
Susan Hayward - French National Cinema, Chp 1 "A brief ecohistory of France's cinema industry 1895 - 1992."
Readings on Hollywood from 1948 - 2000 |
| Thomas Schatz - Old Hollywood/New Hollywood: Ritual, Art and Society, Chp 7 ("Hollywood in Transition") and Chp 8 ("The New Hollywood") |
| Janet Wasko - Hollywood Today. |
| Janet Wasko - Hollywood in the Information Age |
| Janet Wasko - "Understanding the Disney Universe" in James Curran and Michael Gurevitch Mass Media and Society (2nd Edition) |
| Stephen Bach - Final Cut (For a description of the emergence of the post-studio system studio) |
| Albert Moran (ed.) - Film Policy: International, National and Regional Perspectives. |
| Martin Dale - The Movie Game |
| Steve Neale and Murray Smith (eds) - Contemporary Hollywood Cinema |
Lecture 9 - International political economy of the media: Technological Convergence, global concentration of media ownership and the pursuit of new media markets.
Study of the twin trends of convergence of old technologies, telecommunications, computing, broadcasting etc. into new ICTs (Information and Communication Technologies) and of the growth of multimedia conglomerates, operating in film, television, publishing and in new media industries. Related to this, this Lecture examines the appearance in national and supranational cultural and economic policy of Information Society policy, questioning the extent to which such policies are primarily driven by social or commercial ends.
Readings |
| Ithiel de Sola Pool - Technologies of Freedom - Chp 3. |
| Information Society Steering Committee - Ireland's Way to the Information Society |
| Cees Hamelink - World Communication |
| Edward S. Herman and Robert W. McChesney - The Global Media: the new missionaries of global capitalism |
| Susan Strange - States and Markets (Part I) |
| Thomas F. Baldwin et al - Convergence: Integrating Media, Information and Communication. |
| Charles Platt "Interactive Entertainment: who writes it?...Who needs it?" in WIRED (UK Edition) Vol. 1, No. 5 (See also WIRED Vol. 1, No. 4 on Experiments with interactive communities) |
| Nicholas Negroponte - Being Digital |
| Bangemann, Martin - "Europe and the global information society": (AKA The Bangemann Report) |
| Who Owns Who (Directory published annually - available in ILAC Centre Library) |
Lecture 10 - The European Union as the new centre for media policy making
Study of European media policy from the 1970s, through the 1990s. Particular focus on "Television Without Frontiers" directive, the MEDIA '95 and MEDIA II programmes. Examination of the countervailing trends of protectionism (as espoused by successive French Govts) against the free market model. Examination of trade relations between Europe (the EU) and America in the age of global culture industries (e.g. the GATT talks and the subsequent development of the World Trade Organisation)
Readings |
| Angus Finney The State of European Cinema |
| Albert Moran (ed.) - Film Policy: International, National and Regional Perspectives. |
| Martin Dale - The Movie Game |
| Karen Siune et al - Dynamics of Media Politics |
| John Hill "The Future of European Cinema" by in Border Crossing: Film in Ireland, Britain and Europe, edited by Hill et al |
| Burgelman, J C & Pauwels C - "Audiovisual Policy and Cultural Identity in Small European States" in Media, Culture and Society |
| Bangemann, Martin - "Europe and the global information society": (AKA The Bangemann Report) |
| Jay Branegan - "Invasion of the Profit-Snatchers" in TIME Magazine, Feb. 27, 1995. |
| Sharon Strover - "Recent Trends in Coproductions: The Demise of the National" in Democracy and communication in New Europe, edited by Farrell Corcoran & Paschal Preston |
| Janet Wasko - "Jurassic Park and the GATT: Hollywood and Europe- An Update" in Democracy and communication in New Europe, edited by Farrell Corcoran & Paschal Preston |
| Andre Lane and Jean-Luc Renaud The Future of the European Audiovisual Industry |
| Audiovisual Policy in the EU is the responsibility of Directorate-General Ten (DG X). Their homepage offers a wealth of basic data on current developments in EU audiovisual policy but offers outline information on past initiatives such as the Television Without Frontiers Directive and the MEDIA programmes. It is available at: "http://europa.eu.int/comm/dg10/avpolicy/index_en.html." |
Lecture 11 - Ireland - Understanding a small country's cinema policy in an international audiovisual industry
The shaping of the Irish cinema industry (effectively from the 1960s) in terms of production activity, distribution and exhibition. Examination of the series of reports on the Irish film industry in the in the early 1990s, with a particular focus on the changing approach to the promotion of film production in Ireland on the part of the state.
Readings on Contemporary Film Policy |
| The Economics of the Arts in Ireland - by Joe Durkan for the Arts Council 1994 |
| Report on the Audiovisual Production Industry in Ireland - Coopers and Lybrand 1992. |
| Special working group on the Film Production Industry: Report to the Taoiseach 24/12/93. |
| IBEC Economic Database on the Irish Film Industry 1993, 1994, 1995 & 1996. |
| Ireland's Audiovisual (Film & Television) Facilities Infrastructure - |
| The Present Infrastructure and Future Needs - prepared by Film Makers Ireland |
| FAS - Training Needs to the Year 2000/ |
| MEDIA Salles Report on the Irish Film Exhibition Industry 1993. (Ask if interested in this document - it's not publicly available in disaggregated form) David Doherty et al - The Last Picture Show: Britain's changing film audience. |
| Film Ireland/Film West Magazine - Various Articles 1993 - 1997. |
| Irish Film and Television Net (IFTN) is the central resource for all things Irish and film related. Its accessible at http://www.iftn.ie |
Readings for purposes of comparison of 1980s/1990s policy approach with that of previous decades: |
Provision for the Arts - the Arts Council 1976 |
Cinema and Ireland - Luke Gibbons et al |
Report of the Enquiry into the Supply and Distribution of Cinema Films - Restrictive Practices Commission 1977. (Only for those interested in exhibition and distribution in Ireland) |